You guys are SO clever! I love BOTH of those answers! Unfortunately, I looked at the comments before really trying to guess and I'm sure one or both of those are the correct solutions. I love these!
It was supposed to be Painting by Numbers but Elise definitely deserves a bonus for The Da Vinci Code, unlike Dan Brown who deserves eternal condemnation for crimes against literature ;)
SPOILER
........
The Da Vinci Code?